Seil Chat

.
I thought this was meant to be a debate, not a hoarding for 'Better Together' propaganda posters.

Oh well. Here's a point by point refutation that someone (not me) has taken the time to put together.



This rebuttal can also be downloaded in higher quality PDF format HERE

And there is another point by point rebuttal of the misinformation contained in the original poster HERE

NickB wrote:.
I thought this was meant to be a debate, not a hoarding for 'Better Together' propaganda posters.

Oh well. Here's a point by point refutation that someone (not me) has taken the time to put together.

This rebuttal can also be downloaded in higher quality PDF format HERE

Ach well............I'm tempted now to post a series of refutations of the refutation and comprehensive rebuttals of the rebuttal but that would bring the whole attempted debate down to silly pettiness so I won't lower myself..

I am seriously at a loss as to why any attempt to put the positive case for not leaving up the United Kingdom seems to cause upset.

longshanks wrote:I'm tempted now to post a series of refutations of the refutation and comprehensive rebuttals of the rebuttal

Why not do so then? That is how debate and argument works.

I think we have reached the end of the 'ready-made' material with my rebuttal poster, so it would probably require more thought that simply sticking up a poster that is publicly available on the Better Together website or elsewhere on the web. Perhaps you could take it one topic or 'reason' at a time.